18 performance review questions for employees and managers.

Send a short selection of these questions before the review. Ask employees and managers to bring one or two concrete examples from the review period. Use the meeting to compare what each person saw and agree the support, actions and follow-up they can both commit to.

For employees
Describe the work, your contribution, what changed and what support would make a difference next time.
For managers
Separate your direct observations, other people’s accounts and conclusions you are drawing from them.
In the room
Discuss differences, agree one realistic priority and record when you will check progress.

How the work comes together

  1. Before

    Select a small set of relevant questions for both participants. Ask each person to prepare from their own experience.

  2. During

    Use concrete examples to compare perspectives. Agree one next action, its owner, and the support needed.

  3. After

    Share the record and follow up on the agreed date. Revise the action if circumstances changed.

Six self-review questions for employees

1. Which piece of work best shows your contribution this period? 2. What part of that work did you personally own? 3. What changed because of the work, and how could someone verify it? 4. Which goal was hardest to make progress on, and what got in the way? 5. What did you change about the way you work after receiving feedback? 6. Which skill or responsibility would you like to develop next, and what support would help?

Offer a simple response shape. Describe the situation, what you did, what you observed and what you want to discuss. Give people time to check dates and examples. Let them include relevant contributions that are less visible in project dashboards, such as helping a colleague recover a stalled task.

Six preparation questions for managers

7. What contribution did you see directly, and when? 8. Which agreed objective does the example relate to? 9. What else could explain the result? 10. What expectations, resources or dependencies shaped what was possible? 11. What feedback did you give during the period, and how did the employee respond? 12. What opportunity or support can you realistically offer next?

Check the whole review period. Include relevant context such as a change in responsibilities, an interrupted project or an agreed adjustment. If you learned about an example from someone else, identify the source appropriately and verify the account before treating it as evidence.

Six questions to discuss together

13. Which contribution do we want to recognize specifically? 14. Where do our accounts match? 15. What difference in perspective should we examine together? 16. What is the most important thing to try or improve next? 17. Who will provide the support we have agreed? 18. When will we check progress, and what will we look for?

You can share the record after the meeting. Include the agreed action, who owns it, the support and a date. If an important observation is disputed, record the difference accurately and decide how you will check it.

Follow-ups for vague or evaluative answers

“Good communicator” is an interpretation. Ask, “Can you give an example of what they communicated and what someone did differently as a result?” If the answer is “They need more ownership,” ask which responsibility was agreed, what happened and whether the person had the authority to act.

If a contribution is described with a metric, ask what the measure covers and how much of the change the person could reasonably influence. A metric can frame a discussion. Pair it with an example of work to understand how the outcome came about.

A worked development action

Imagine an employee wants to get better at leading customer handovers. Their manager agrees to let them run the next two routine handovers, provides an agenda and observes the first one. After each, the employee and manager will review whether the receiving colleague could identify the open actions and their owners. They set a date after the second handover to agree the next step.

Keep the action within the employee’s control and make sure the manager’s commitment is explicit. Acas describes appraisal as one part of performance management and recommends that regular feedback and check-ins continue between formal reviews.

Questions that come up

How many performance review questions should I send?

Start with the few questions that match the role, review period and purpose. Four to six before the review can be a workable starting point if each person has time to bring examples.

Should managers and employees answer the same questions?

Use a shared question about the same work or period to compare perspectives. Add role-specific follow-ups for what each person observed, contributed or could support.

How do I handle conflicting accounts?

Ask what each person could see and whether both mean the same event. Make room for disagreement in the record and agree what evidence could clarify it.

Bring one performance question.

See the product on a question like yours, and what a first campaign could involve.

Book a demo