lontra
All sample studies

Where information is lost at nursing shift handovers

Finished 10 of 10 people answered Deep Study A 400-bed general hospital

Sample study · simulated participants

Report

Written by Lontra from 10 conversations, 2 shared documents and 4 Deep Study conversations.

The answer

Handovers lose what changed during the shift, because the form only records what stayed the same.

Allergies, mobility and 'as per drug chart' are on the form. A change made in the afternoon is not, so it travels by voice and depends on the handover not being cut short.

What people said

Medication changes are passed on by word of mouth 7 of 10 people Strong signal

A change made after the form was written is told to whoever is nearest, and it reaches the next shift only if the person who made it is there and remembers. Nurses, the pharmacist and the doctor all describe the same route. The junior doctor assumes telling the nearest nurse is enough.

“If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.”Staff nurse, 12 years in role
Show all 4 quotes and their conversations
  1. “If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.”

    Staff nurse, 12 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

    Staff nurse

    Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

    Lontra

    Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

    Staff nurse

    Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

    Lontra

    What does 'said' look like?

    Staff nurse

    In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example from a recent week?

    Staff nurse

    Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

    Lontra

    What did it cost, that time?

    Staff nurse

    Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

    Lontra

    How often does a change like that happen?

    Staff nurse

    Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

    Lontra

    What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

    Staff nurse

    You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

  2. “Verbally. Medication changes, mostly.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  3. “Word of mouth. I tell the nurse looking after the bed and the doctor.”

    Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role · Covers four wards on weekdays

    Lontra

    How do you hear about medication changes on the wards?

    Ward pharmacist

    I see the chart, so I see what's current. I don't see what was done at four unless someone tells me. I'm on each ward at ten and at two, so I see about half of a day's changes.

    Lontra

    When you recommend a change, how does the ward find out?

    Ward pharmacist

    Word of mouth. I tell the nurse looking after the bed and the doctor. It's not on the form, I've no way of putting it there. Sometimes I leave a sticky note on the chart folder, which is a terrible idea, but it's what I've got.

    Lontra

    How many changes are made in a day on a ward?

    Ward pharmacist

    Eight to ten, if I had to guess. Not all of them matter much. I haven't counted and I don't know of anyone who has.

    Lontra

    What do nurses ask you?

    Ward pharmacist

    'Has that gone in?' I get asked it a lot. It's because they can't tell from the chart whether something's new.

    Lontra

    What would help?

    Ward pharmacist

    A way to flag 'changed today' on the chart itself. Not on a separate form. It seems obvious.

  4. “I change the chart and tell whoever's nearest. I assume that's enough.”

    Junior doctor, second year

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Junior doctor, second year · Medical ward, ward rounds in the morning

    Lontra

    What happens after you change something on a chart?

    Junior doctor

    I tell the nurse who's nearest, or the bay's nurse if I can find them. Then I carry on.

    Lontra

    Do you know whether it reaches the next shift?

    Junior doctor

    I assume so. I change the chart and tell whoever's nearest. I assume that's enough.

    Lontra

    What makes you assume that?

    Junior doctor

    The chart's the record. It's what I was taught. I didn't know there was a separate handover form until you asked.

    Lontra

    When do you make most of your changes?

    Junior doctor

    After the ward round, three, four o'clock. Right before the late shift hands over. Which I suppose is the worst time.

    Lontra

    Is there a way to flag a change for handover?

    Junior doctor

    There's a free-text box on the electronic note. I don't know who reads it.

    Lontra

    Would you do anything differently if you knew?

    Junior doctor

    I'd tell the nurse in charge as well. That's easy, I just don't think of it.

The form lists what stays the same, and a change has one small box or nowhere 6 of 10 people Strong signal

Allergies, mobility, diet and 'as per drug chart' are on the form. What changed during the shift has one line labelled Other, if it is used at all. People fill it with 'see chart' because the chart is current but does not show that something is new.

“Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room.”Staff nurse, 12 years in role
Show all 4 quotes and their conversations
  1. “Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room.”

    Staff nurse, 12 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

    Staff nurse

    Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

    Lontra

    Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

    Staff nurse

    Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

    Lontra

    What does 'said' look like?

    Staff nurse

    In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example from a recent week?

    Staff nurse

    Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

    Lontra

    What did it cost, that time?

    Staff nurse

    Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

    Lontra

    How often does a change like that happen?

    Staff nurse

    Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

    Lontra

    What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

    Staff nurse

    You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

  2. “It doesn't show that something changed at four.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  3. “The form can't hold what changed, there isn't room.”

    Nurse in charge, 15 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Orthopaedic ward, days

    Lontra

    How does handover work on your ward?

    Nurse in charge

    Same every shift. We do all of it at the bedside. The outgoing and incoming nurse go round together. That's the policy and it works.

    Lontra

    How does the form fit in?

    Nurse in charge

    It's a prompt. It gets the nurse going, the real information is said. The form can't hold what changed, there isn't room.

    Lontra

    What gets said that is not on the form?

    Nurse in charge

    Anything on medication that moved during the shift. Doses, times, something stopped. I tell my staff, if it's not on the chart yet, it has to be said out loud.

    Lontra

    Earlier you said all of it is done at the bedside. Which is closer to a normal shift?

    Nurse in charge

    Fair. Bedside is the policy and it's what I'd say in front of the matron. In practice it's the station when we're short, and the bays that need it get walked. Half and half, I'd say.

    Lontra

    What does that do to what gets passed on?

    Nurse in charge

    The station version is quicker and it's all voice. At the bedside you've got the chart in front of you. At the station you're relying on memory.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of a handover?

    Nurse in charge

    The phone. Someone's relative at the desk. Staff being pulled off to answer, in the middle of the report.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Nurse in charge

    A 'what changed' line on the form, and fifteen minutes protected with nobody pulled off to answer the phone.

  4. “A line for changes, and everyone fills it in, even if it says none.”

    Bank nurse, 2 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Bank nurse, 2 years in role · Works across wards, a different one most weeks

    Lontra

    What is handover like for you, working on different wards?

    Bank nurse

    Different every time. Every ward has the same form but each uses it differently. One fills in everything, one just the top. You walk in and work out the local rules.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is blank?

    Bank nurse

    That's the thing. Blank might mean nothing's changed, or it might mean nobody got to it. I can't tell. So I ask.

    Lontra

    Who do you ask?

    Bank nurse

    The nurse who's still there. If they've gone, I ring the ward from the last shift.

    Lontra

    How often does that happen?

    Bank nurse

    Most shifts. Two, three calls in the first hour. Plus reading everything again.

    Lontra

    What do you do about medication specifically?

    Bank nurse

    I check the chart for each one and ask at the bedside, 'anything changed today?' People are fine with it. It's just an extra couple of minutes a bay that nobody has counted.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Bank nurse

    A line for changes, and everyone fills it in, even if it says none. Then blank means blank.

The first hour of a shift goes on re-checking and ringing the last shift 6 of 10 people Strong signal

Nurses re-read the chart for every patient and ring the previous shift when something does not match. People put it at 10 to 20 minutes of calls on top of checking, most shifts. Nobody has counted it.

“It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.”Staff nurse, 12 years in role
Show all 4 quotes and their conversations
  1. “It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.”

    Staff nurse, 12 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

    Staff nurse

    Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

    Lontra

    Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

    Staff nurse

    Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

    Lontra

    What does 'said' look like?

    Staff nurse

    In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example from a recent week?

    Staff nurse

    Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

    Lontra

    What did it cost, that time?

    Staff nurse

    Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

    Lontra

    How often does a change like that happen?

    Staff nurse

    Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

    Lontra

    What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

    Staff nurse

    You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

  2. “Ring the last shift if something doesn't match.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  3. “'Has that gone in?' I get asked it a lot.”

    Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role · Covers four wards on weekdays

    Lontra

    How do you hear about medication changes on the wards?

    Ward pharmacist

    I see the chart, so I see what's current. I don't see what was done at four unless someone tells me. I'm on each ward at ten and at two, so I see about half of a day's changes.

    Lontra

    When you recommend a change, how does the ward find out?

    Ward pharmacist

    Word of mouth. I tell the nurse looking after the bed and the doctor. It's not on the form, I've no way of putting it there. Sometimes I leave a sticky note on the chart folder, which is a terrible idea, but it's what I've got.

    Lontra

    How many changes are made in a day on a ward?

    Ward pharmacist

    Eight to ten, if I had to guess. Not all of them matter much. I haven't counted and I don't know of anyone who has.

    Lontra

    What do nurses ask you?

    Ward pharmacist

    'Has that gone in?' I get asked it a lot. It's because they can't tell from the chart whether something's new.

    Lontra

    What would help?

    Ward pharmacist

    A way to flag 'changed today' on the chart itself. Not on a separate form. It seems obvious.

  4. “Two, three calls in the first hour.”

    Bank nurse, 2 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Bank nurse, 2 years in role · Works across wards, a different one most weeks

    Lontra

    What is handover like for you, working on different wards?

    Bank nurse

    Different every time. Every ward has the same form but each uses it differently. One fills in everything, one just the top. You walk in and work out the local rules.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is blank?

    Bank nurse

    That's the thing. Blank might mean nothing's changed, or it might mean nobody got to it. I can't tell. So I ask.

    Lontra

    Who do you ask?

    Bank nurse

    The nurse who's still there. If they've gone, I ring the ward from the last shift.

    Lontra

    How often does that happen?

    Bank nurse

    Most shifts. Two, three calls in the first hour. Plus reading everything again.

    Lontra

    What do you do about medication specifically?

    Bank nurse

    I check the chart for each one and ask at the bedside, 'anything changed today?' People are fine with it. It's just an extra couple of minutes a bay that nobody has counted.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Bank nurse

    A line for changes, and everyone fills it in, even if it says none. Then blank means blank.

When the ward is short, handover moves from the bedside to the station 5 of 10 people Strong signal

Bedside handover is the policy. On a short-staffed shift or a bad night the report is given in the office and the bays are walked after. A nurse in charge who first said all of it is at the bedside counted six of fourteen in two weeks.

“It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station.”Staff nurse, 3 years in role
Show all 4 quotes and their conversations
  1. “It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  2. “At the station you're relying on memory.”

    Nurse in charge, 15 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Orthopaedic ward, days

    Lontra

    How does handover work on your ward?

    Nurse in charge

    Same every shift. We do all of it at the bedside. The outgoing and incoming nurse go round together. That's the policy and it works.

    Lontra

    How does the form fit in?

    Nurse in charge

    It's a prompt. It gets the nurse going, the real information is said. The form can't hold what changed, there isn't room.

    Lontra

    What gets said that is not on the form?

    Nurse in charge

    Anything on medication that moved during the shift. Doses, times, something stopped. I tell my staff, if it's not on the chart yet, it has to be said out loud.

    Lontra

    Earlier you said all of it is done at the bedside. Which is closer to a normal shift?

    Nurse in charge

    Fair. Bedside is the policy and it's what I'd say in front of the matron. In practice it's the station when we're short, and the bays that need it get walked. Half and half, I'd say.

    Lontra

    What does that do to what gets passed on?

    Nurse in charge

    The station version is quicker and it's all voice. At the bedside you've got the chart in front of you. At the station you're relying on memory.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of a handover?

    Nurse in charge

    The phone. Someone's relative at the desk. Staff being pulled off to answer, in the middle of the report.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Nurse in charge

    A 'what changed' line on the form, and fifteen minutes protected with nobody pulled off to answer the phone.

  3. “On a bad night the report's all in the office and we only walk the bays after.”

    Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role · Medical ward, 30 beds, five nurses on a night

    Lontra

    What does a handover into the night shift look like?

    Night nurse in charge

    Half seven, report from the late nurse in charge, ten minutes if we're lucky, then the bays. Thirty beds, five nurses. Each nurse gets their six from whoever had them. On a bad night the report's all in the office and we only walk the bays after.

    Lontra

    How does a change made during the shift reach you?

    Night nurse in charge

    Said, mostly. Sometimes the late nurse has written it on a scrap, or the back of the form. I've seen it on a glove box. If it's in the Other box I'll see it, and that's about one handover in four.

    Lontra

    Roughly one in four?

    Night nurse in charge

    I'd say. I haven't counted.

    Lontra

    What interrupts a handover?

    Night nurse in charge

    Bleep, phone, a relative at the desk. The doctor wanting a word about something else. We get pulled off in the middle of someone's sentence and pick up wherever we are.

    Lontra

    What do you do when you pick up in the middle?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ask them to go back. Or if they've gone home, ring the ward later.

    Lontra

    How long does that take?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ten minutes. Not long, but there's several a night. And the first drug round is waiting.

    Lontra

    Who owns the form?

    Night nurse in charge

    Somebody in the clinical systems office. Matron would know.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Night nurse in charge

    A changes box. Truly. And a place to write which bay to go to first.

  4. “Sometimes at the bedside, sometimes by the desk.”

    Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role · Surgical ward

    Lontra

    How do you find out what has changed for your patients at the start of a shift?

    Healthcare assistant

    The nurse tells us.

    Lontra

    When does she tell you?

    Healthcare assistant

    When she can. Sometimes at the bedside, sometimes by the desk.

    Lontra

    Do you see the form?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. I don't write on it.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example of something you were told late?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. It's fine, mostly.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of handover?

    Healthcare assistant

    Call bells. Phones. Visitors early. Everything.

    Lontra

    What does a blank box on the form mean?

    Healthcare assistant

    Dunno. Nothing, I'd say.

Phones, bells and relatives interrupt the report in the middle of a sentence 5 of 10 people Strong signal

Handover is picked up wherever it was dropped, or not picked up. People ask the speaker to go back if they are still there, and ring the ward later if not.

“Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone.”Staff nurse, 3 years in role
Show all 3 quotes and their conversations
  1. “Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  2. “Call bells. Phones. Visitors early. Everything.”

    Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role · Surgical ward

    Lontra

    How do you find out what has changed for your patients at the start of a shift?

    Healthcare assistant

    The nurse tells us.

    Lontra

    When does she tell you?

    Healthcare assistant

    When she can. Sometimes at the bedside, sometimes by the desk.

    Lontra

    Do you see the form?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. I don't write on it.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example of something you were told late?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. It's fine, mostly.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of handover?

    Healthcare assistant

    Call bells. Phones. Visitors early. Everything.

    Lontra

    What does a blank box on the form mean?

    Healthcare assistant

    Dunno. Nothing, I'd say.

  3. “We get pulled off in the middle of someone's sentence and pick up wherever we are.”

    Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role · Medical ward, 30 beds, five nurses on a night

    Lontra

    What does a handover into the night shift look like?

    Night nurse in charge

    Half seven, report from the late nurse in charge, ten minutes if we're lucky, then the bays. Thirty beds, five nurses. Each nurse gets their six from whoever had them. On a bad night the report's all in the office and we only walk the bays after.

    Lontra

    How does a change made during the shift reach you?

    Night nurse in charge

    Said, mostly. Sometimes the late nurse has written it on a scrap, or the back of the form. I've seen it on a glove box. If it's in the Other box I'll see it, and that's about one handover in four.

    Lontra

    Roughly one in four?

    Night nurse in charge

    I'd say. I haven't counted.

    Lontra

    What interrupts a handover?

    Night nurse in charge

    Bleep, phone, a relative at the desk. The doctor wanting a word about something else. We get pulled off in the middle of someone's sentence and pick up wherever we are.

    Lontra

    What do you do when you pick up in the middle?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ask them to go back. Or if they've gone home, ring the ward later.

    Lontra

    How long does that take?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ten minutes. Not long, but there's several a night. And the first drug round is waiting.

    Lontra

    Who owns the form?

    Night nurse in charge

    Somebody in the clinical systems office. Matron would know.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Night nurse in charge

    A changes box. Truly. And a place to write which bay to go to first.

A blank box can mean nothing changed, or nobody got to it 3 of 10 people Emerging

A newly qualified nurse, a healthcare assistant and a bank nurse who changes ward each week all describe learning what a blank box means by asking whoever is closest. Nobody told them. It is a small group in this study, but each reaches the same reading independently.

“Not sure. I assume nothing's changed.”Staff nurse, 8 months in role
Show all 3 quotes and their conversations
  1. “Not sure. I assume nothing's changed.”

    Staff nurse, 8 months in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 8 months in role · Medical ward, night shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover when you start a night shift?

    Staff nurse

    Report in the office. Then we go round.

    Lontra

    How long does it take?

    Staff nurse

    Depends. About fifteen minutes. Longer if it's a bad day.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way?

    Staff nurse

    The phone. Bells.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    The usual stuff. Allergies, mobility. Drugs, as per chart.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is empty?

    Staff nurse

    Not sure. I assume nothing's changed.

    Lontra

    Has anyone told you what an empty box means?

    Staff nurse

    No. I just ask if I'm not sure.

    Lontra

    What do you do in your first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Checking. Mostly checking.

  2. “Dunno. Nothing, I'd say.”

    Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role · Surgical ward

    Lontra

    How do you find out what has changed for your patients at the start of a shift?

    Healthcare assistant

    The nurse tells us.

    Lontra

    When does she tell you?

    Healthcare assistant

    When she can. Sometimes at the bedside, sometimes by the desk.

    Lontra

    Do you see the form?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. I don't write on it.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example of something you were told late?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. It's fine, mostly.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of handover?

    Healthcare assistant

    Call bells. Phones. Visitors early. Everything.

    Lontra

    What does a blank box on the form mean?

    Healthcare assistant

    Dunno. Nothing, I'd say.

  3. “Blank might mean nothing's changed, or it might mean nobody got to it.”

    Bank nurse, 2 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Bank nurse, 2 years in role · Works across wards, a different one most weeks

    Lontra

    What is handover like for you, working on different wards?

    Bank nurse

    Different every time. Every ward has the same form but each uses it differently. One fills in everything, one just the top. You walk in and work out the local rules.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is blank?

    Bank nurse

    That's the thing. Blank might mean nothing's changed, or it might mean nobody got to it. I can't tell. So I ask.

    Lontra

    Who do you ask?

    Bank nurse

    The nurse who's still there. If they've gone, I ring the ward from the last shift.

    Lontra

    How often does that happen?

    Bank nurse

    Most shifts. Two, three calls in the first hour. Plus reading everything again.

    Lontra

    What do you do about medication specifically?

    Bank nurse

    I check the chart for each one and ask at the bedside, 'anything changed today?' People are fine with it. It's just an extra couple of minutes a bay that nobody has counted.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Bank nurse

    A line for changes, and everyone fills it in, even if it says none. Then blank means blank.

Where accounts differ

Whether the chart already tells the next shift what changed

Nursing management and the junior doctor treat the electronic chart as the record that makes a separate note unnecessary. Nurses on the wards say the chart shows what is current, not that something is new.

On the wards 3 people
  1. “More often it just gets said.”

    Staff nurse, 12 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

    Staff nurse

    Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

    Lontra

    Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

    Staff nurse

    Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

    Lontra

    What does 'said' look like?

    Staff nurse

    In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example from a recent week?

    Staff nurse

    Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

    Lontra

    What did it cost, that time?

    Staff nurse

    Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

    Lontra

    How often does a change like that happen?

    Staff nurse

    Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

    Lontra

    What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

    Staff nurse

    You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

  2. “So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.”

    Staff nurse, 3 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  3. “if it's not on the chart yet, it has to be said out loud.”

    Nurse in charge, 15 years in role

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Orthopaedic ward, days

    Lontra

    How does handover work on your ward?

    Nurse in charge

    Same every shift. We do all of it at the bedside. The outgoing and incoming nurse go round together. That's the policy and it works.

    Lontra

    How does the form fit in?

    Nurse in charge

    It's a prompt. It gets the nurse going, the real information is said. The form can't hold what changed, there isn't room.

    Lontra

    What gets said that is not on the form?

    Nurse in charge

    Anything on medication that moved during the shift. Doses, times, something stopped. I tell my staff, if it's not on the chart yet, it has to be said out loud.

    Lontra

    Earlier you said all of it is done at the bedside. Which is closer to a normal shift?

    Nurse in charge

    Fair. Bedside is the policy and it's what I'd say in front of the matron. In practice it's the station when we're short, and the bays that need it get walked. Half and half, I'd say.

    Lontra

    What does that do to what gets passed on?

    Nurse in charge

    The station version is quicker and it's all voice. At the bedside you've got the chart in front of you. At the station you're relying on memory.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of a handover?

    Nurse in charge

    The phone. Someone's relative at the desk. Staff being pulled off to answer, in the middle of the report.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Nurse in charge

    A 'what changed' line on the form, and fifteen minutes protected with nobody pulled off to answer the phone.

In nursing management 1 person
  1. “So the nurse's job is to look at the chart, not to copy it.”

    Matron, 20 years in nursing

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Matron, 20 years in nursing · Responsible for the handover policy across five wards

    Lontra

    How is handover meant to work across the wards you are responsible for?

    Matron

    Bedside handover at the shift change, outgoing and incoming nurse together, with the standard form as a prompt and the electronic chart as the record. We've had that policy for three years.

    Lontra

    How do you know it is followed?

    Matron

    Audit. We observe a sample each quarter. I think we have a good picture.

    Lontra

    What does the form say about medication?

    Matron

    It says 'as per drug chart'. The chart's electronic and always current. So the nurse's job is to look at the chart, not to copy it. Copying would add error.

    Lontra

    What do the wards tell you?

    Matron

    That they don't have time. I take that seriously, but I also think there's some habit in it. The chart is there.

    Lontra

    What would a change made at four look like on the chart?

    Matron

    It would be the current order, with the time. So the information is there.

    Lontra

    Would a nurse starting a shift see, without opening the history, that it had changed?

    Matron

    Not in the headline view, no. You'd have to open the history. That's a fair point. I hadn't thought about it from that side.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Matron

    I'd want to look at the audit again with this in mind. I wouldn't add a line to the form without evidence that people would use it.

Prescribers 1 person
  1. “The chart's the record. It's what I was taught.”

    Junior doctor, second year

    Open the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Junior doctor, second year · Medical ward, ward rounds in the morning

    Lontra

    What happens after you change something on a chart?

    Junior doctor

    I tell the nurse who's nearest, or the bay's nurse if I can find them. Then I carry on.

    Lontra

    Do you know whether it reaches the next shift?

    Junior doctor

    I assume so. I change the chart and tell whoever's nearest. I assume that's enough.

    Lontra

    What makes you assume that?

    Junior doctor

    The chart's the record. It's what I was taught. I didn't know there was a separate handover form until you asked.

    Lontra

    When do you make most of your changes?

    Junior doctor

    After the ward round, three, four o'clock. Right before the late shift hands over. Which I suppose is the worst time.

    Lontra

    Is there a way to flag a change for handover?

    Junior doctor

    There's a free-text box on the electronic note. I don't know who reads it.

    Lontra

    Would you do anything differently if you knew?

    Junior doctor

    I'd tell the nurse in charge as well. That's easy, I just don't think of it.

Documents

Ward handover form, template version 4 Shared by a participant

A one-page form with a line per patient. Every field records something that stays the same; the medication line reads 'as per drug chart', and the only place for a change is a single line labelled Other.

Shared by: Staff nurse, 12 years in role

Open the document

The line Lontra asked about is marked.

WARD HANDOVER FORM, TEMPLATE VERSION 4

One line per patient. Complete before the report.

Bed: ____ Patient label: [sticker]

Reason for admission: ________________

Mobility: independent / with help / bed-bound

Diet and fluids: ________________

Allergies: ________________ (as per chart)

Medication: as per drug chart

Last observations: time ____ (see chart)

Plan for next shift: ________________

Other: ________________ (one line)

What Lontra asked about it

Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

Lontra

To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

Staff nurse

Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

Lontra

What is on the form?

Staff nurse

Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

Lontra

Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

Staff nurse

Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

Lontra

What does 'said' look like?

Staff nurse

In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

Lontra

Can you give me an example from a recent week?

Staff nurse

Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

Lontra

What did it cost, that time?

Staff nurse

Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

Lontra

How often does a change like that happen?

Staff nurse

Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

Lontra

What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

Staff nurse

You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

Handover audit, five wards, one month Shared by a participant

The hospital's own audit: most handovers start on time, but bedside handover varies widely and the medication line is filled in by hand in about one handover in five.

Shared by: Matron, 20 years in nursing · Shared during Deep Study

Open the document

The line Lontra asked about is marked.

WardHandovers observedStarted within 15 min (%)At the bedside (%)Interrupted at least once (%)Medication line filled in by hand (%)
Medical A2488627921
Medical B2282458618
Surgical A2692736927
Surgical B2075409015
Orthopaedic1889676133

What Lontra asked about it

Excerpt from the Deep Study conversation with: Matron, 20 years in nursing · Responsible for the handover policy across five wards

Lontra

Last time you wanted to look at the audit again with the chart in mind. Did you?

Matron

I did, it's attached. One month, five wards. I'd read it before as good news, because most handovers start on time.

Lontra

On Medical B the audit shows bedside handover in 45 of 100 handovers and the medication line updated by hand in 18. What do you make of those two figures?

Matron

That the policy and the practice are further apart than I'd said. And that the medication line is updated by hand about one handover in five. I'd assumed higher. I hadn't put those columns side by side.

Lontra

Would the wards say the form is a prompt, or a record?

Matron

A prompt, and the real information is spoken. I thought that was how it should be. I hadn't thought about what happens when the speaking gets cut short.

Lontra

Is there someone else we should talk to about the form?

Matron

The clinical systems nurse who looks after the template. She'll know what's been asked for.

What we still don’t know

  • How many medication changes a ward makes after the form is written.One nurse counted four, two and five on her last three late shifts; the pharmacist guessed eight to ten across a ward in a day. Nobody counts them and the chart does not report them, so this study cannot say how many are passed on by voice alone.
  • Why the 'changes this shift' line was dropped from an earlier version of the form.Two people remember it. The template's owner found the change log, which says 'simplified to one page', but not why that line went and not another.

Deep Study

A few days after the last conversation, Deep Study went back to three people whose answers left a question open, and spoke to one colleague the matron suggested.

Staff nurse, 12 years in role Asked again

Shared the form and said something moves most shifts. How many changes, and did each one reach the night nurse?

Open the conversation

Excerpt from the conversation with: ·

Matron, 20 years in nursing Asked again

Described the audit as a good picture. What do its columns show when they are read together?

Open the conversation

Excerpt from the conversation with: ·

Nurse in charge, 15 years in role Asked again

Said first that all handover is at the bedside, then half and half. Which is closer, and what decides it?

Open the conversation

Excerpt from the conversation with: ·

Clinical systems nurse Suggested by: Matron, 20 years in nursing

Suggested by the matron: the clinical systems nurse who maintains the form knows what has been asked for.

Open the conversation

Excerpt from the conversation with: ·

What Deep Study added

  • The audit counted most handovers as starting on time and was read as good news, but it also shows bedside handover from 40 to 73 in 100 and the medication line filled in by hand in about one handover in five.
  • Bedside versus station is decided by staffing: every station handover on one ward in two weeks fell on a day someone was off or a late admission arrived.
  • There have been five requests for a changes line in two years, all from wards. They sit in a list and nobody owns the decision.
  • The matron, who had described the chart as enough, said she had not thought about it from the nurse's side, and wants the audit looked at again.

Who took part

People are described by their role and context, as in any Lontra study.

  • Staff nurse, 12 years in role Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts · 21 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    To start, what happens at handover on your ward, from the moment the shift changes?

    Staff nurse

    Early shift comes in for quarter past seven, we sit in the office for the report from the night nurse in charge, then we go round the bays. In theory. We've got twenty-eight beds, so it's the form plus whatever people say.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    Reason in, mobility, diet, allergies, drugs as per chart, obs. I've shared a copy, the blank one.

    Lontra

    Thank you for the form. The medication line reads 'as per drug chart'. If a dose was changed at four in the afternoon, where would that go on this form?

    Staff nurse

    Nowhere, really. You'd write it in the Other box at the bottom if there's room. There's room for about one line. More often it just gets said.

    Lontra

    What does 'said' look like?

    Staff nurse

    In the office, or at the bedside, if the person remembers. If the nurse who made the change is off on her break, it can stop with her.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example from a recent week?

    Staff nurse

    Tuesday, on a late. I'd had a change at four, the timing of a dose. I'd written it on my own scrap of paper and it never made it onto the form. At eight the night nurse asked me about that bed and I told her. If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.

    Lontra

    What did it cost, that time?

    Staff nurse

    Not much. Ten minutes of me reading her my scrap and her writing it up. But that was because she asked.

    Lontra

    How often does a change like that happen?

    Staff nurse

    Most shifts, something. On a medical ward there's always something moved in the afternoon.

    Lontra

    What is the first hour of a shift like, for you?

    Staff nurse

    You're double-checking. I open the chart for every patient, in case. It takes most of the first hour before I trust I know what's happened.

    Excerpt from the Deep Study conversation with: Staff nurse, 12 years in role · Medical ward, 28 beds, early and late shifts

    Lontra

    You shared the blank form. Has it always looked like this?

    Staff nurse

    I asked someone who's been here twenty years. She remembers a version with a 'changes this shift' line and a tick for none. It went when the form was cut to one side.

    Lontra

    You said something is moved most shifts. Did you count on your last few lates?

    Staff nurse

    I did. Four, two and five changes after the form was written. All but one went down on my scrap of paper. One I only said.

    Lontra

    Did that one reach the night nurse?

    Staff nurse

    Yes, because I said it at the bedside. It's the ones I say in the office I worry about, there's more going on.

  • Staff nurse, 3 years in role Surgical ward, early shifts · 17 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 3 years in role · Surgical ward, early shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover on your ward?

    Staff nurse

    Night staff give us the report in the office, ten minutes, then a quick walk round the bays. It's supposed to be at the bedside. A lot of the time it's the station. Who's who, the plan, what's different.

    Lontra

    How does the 'what's different' part get passed on?

    Staff nurse

    Verbally. Medication changes, mostly. There's no line for them on the form, there's a little box at the bottom that says Other. I put 'see chart' in it half the time.

    Lontra

    Why 'see chart'?

    Staff nurse

    Because writing it takes a minute and I've got six patients to give. And honestly, the chart's right there.

    Lontra

    What does the chart show?

    Staff nurse

    What's current. It doesn't show that something changed at four. So you read the chart and think it's always been that. It looks the same either way.

    Lontra

    How long does the report take when it's busy?

    Staff nurse

    Ten minutes if we're lucky. Twenty-five if someone's rung from A&E, or a call bell, or the phone. It gets cut short, then I do the bedside bits on my own.

    Lontra

    What do you do in the first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Check the notes for my six against what I was told. Ring the last shift if something doesn't match. Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.

    Lontra

    Is there anything you would change?

    Staff nurse

    A line for 'changed this shift' on the form. Even just a tick box. At least it would make people say it.

  • Staff nurse, 8 months in role Medical ward, night shifts · 5 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Staff nurse, 8 months in role · Medical ward, night shifts

    Lontra

    What happens at handover when you start a night shift?

    Staff nurse

    Report in the office. Then we go round.

    Lontra

    How long does it take?

    Staff nurse

    Depends. About fifteen minutes. Longer if it's a bad day.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way?

    Staff nurse

    The phone. Bells.

    Lontra

    What is on the form?

    Staff nurse

    The usual stuff. Allergies, mobility. Drugs, as per chart.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is empty?

    Staff nurse

    Not sure. I assume nothing's changed.

    Lontra

    Has anyone told you what an empty box means?

    Staff nurse

    No. I just ask if I'm not sure.

    Lontra

    What do you do in your first hour?

    Staff nurse

    Checking. Mostly checking.

  • Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role Surgical ward · 6 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Healthcare assistant, 6 years in role · Surgical ward

    Lontra

    How do you find out what has changed for your patients at the start of a shift?

    Healthcare assistant

    The nurse tells us.

    Lontra

    When does she tell you?

    Healthcare assistant

    When she can. Sometimes at the bedside, sometimes by the desk.

    Lontra

    Do you see the form?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. I don't write on it.

    Lontra

    Can you give me an example of something you were told late?

    Healthcare assistant

    Not really. It's fine, mostly.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of handover?

    Healthcare assistant

    Call bells. Phones. Visitors early. Everything.

    Lontra

    What does a blank box on the form mean?

    Healthcare assistant

    Dunno. Nothing, I'd say.

  • Nurse in charge, 15 years in role Orthopaedic ward, days · 18 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Orthopaedic ward, days

    Lontra

    How does handover work on your ward?

    Nurse in charge

    Same every shift. We do all of it at the bedside. The outgoing and incoming nurse go round together. That's the policy and it works.

    Lontra

    How does the form fit in?

    Nurse in charge

    It's a prompt. It gets the nurse going, the real information is said. The form can't hold what changed, there isn't room.

    Lontra

    What gets said that is not on the form?

    Nurse in charge

    Anything on medication that moved during the shift. Doses, times, something stopped. I tell my staff, if it's not on the chart yet, it has to be said out loud.

    Lontra

    Earlier you said all of it is done at the bedside. Which is closer to a normal shift?

    Nurse in charge

    Fair. Bedside is the policy and it's what I'd say in front of the matron. In practice it's the station when we're short, and the bays that need it get walked. Half and half, I'd say.

    Lontra

    What does that do to what gets passed on?

    Nurse in charge

    The station version is quicker and it's all voice. At the bedside you've got the chart in front of you. At the station you're relying on memory.

    Lontra

    What gets in the way of a handover?

    Nurse in charge

    The phone. Someone's relative at the desk. Staff being pulled off to answer, in the middle of the report.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Nurse in charge

    A 'what changed' line on the form, and fifteen minutes protected with nobody pulled off to answer the phone.

    Excerpt from the Deep Study conversation with: Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Orthopaedic ward, days

    Lontra

    You said handover on your ward is about half bedside and half at the station. Did you count since?

    Nurse in charge

    I did a tick sheet for two weeks. Fourteen handovers, eight at the station, six at the bedside.

    Lontra

    What did the station days have in common?

    Nurse in charge

    Every one of them was a day somebody was off sick or a late admission arrived. It wasn't choice, it was the staffing.

    Lontra

    Do you think the other wards are the same?

    Nurse in charge

    Medical B has the worst of it, I'd guess. They've got more beds to a nurse than I do.

  • Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role Medical ward, 30 beds, five nurses on a night · 16 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role · Medical ward, 30 beds, five nurses on a night

    Lontra

    What does a handover into the night shift look like?

    Night nurse in charge

    Half seven, report from the late nurse in charge, ten minutes if we're lucky, then the bays. Thirty beds, five nurses. Each nurse gets their six from whoever had them. On a bad night the report's all in the office and we only walk the bays after.

    Lontra

    How does a change made during the shift reach you?

    Night nurse in charge

    Said, mostly. Sometimes the late nurse has written it on a scrap, or the back of the form. I've seen it on a glove box. If it's in the Other box I'll see it, and that's about one handover in four.

    Lontra

    Roughly one in four?

    Night nurse in charge

    I'd say. I haven't counted.

    Lontra

    What interrupts a handover?

    Night nurse in charge

    Bleep, phone, a relative at the desk. The doctor wanting a word about something else. We get pulled off in the middle of someone's sentence and pick up wherever we are.

    Lontra

    What do you do when you pick up in the middle?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ask them to go back. Or if they've gone home, ring the ward later.

    Lontra

    How long does that take?

    Night nurse in charge

    Ten minutes. Not long, but there's several a night. And the first drug round is waiting.

    Lontra

    Who owns the form?

    Night nurse in charge

    Somebody in the clinical systems office. Matron would know.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Night nurse in charge

    A changes box. Truly. And a place to write which bay to go to first.

  • Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role Covers four wards on weekdays · 14 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role · Covers four wards on weekdays

    Lontra

    How do you hear about medication changes on the wards?

    Ward pharmacist

    I see the chart, so I see what's current. I don't see what was done at four unless someone tells me. I'm on each ward at ten and at two, so I see about half of a day's changes.

    Lontra

    When you recommend a change, how does the ward find out?

    Ward pharmacist

    Word of mouth. I tell the nurse looking after the bed and the doctor. It's not on the form, I've no way of putting it there. Sometimes I leave a sticky note on the chart folder, which is a terrible idea, but it's what I've got.

    Lontra

    How many changes are made in a day on a ward?

    Ward pharmacist

    Eight to ten, if I had to guess. Not all of them matter much. I haven't counted and I don't know of anyone who has.

    Lontra

    What do nurses ask you?

    Ward pharmacist

    'Has that gone in?' I get asked it a lot. It's because they can't tell from the chart whether something's new.

    Lontra

    What would help?

    Ward pharmacist

    A way to flag 'changed today' on the chart itself. Not on a separate form. It seems obvious.

  • Junior doctor, second year Medical ward, ward rounds in the morning · 9 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Junior doctor, second year · Medical ward, ward rounds in the morning

    Lontra

    What happens after you change something on a chart?

    Junior doctor

    I tell the nurse who's nearest, or the bay's nurse if I can find them. Then I carry on.

    Lontra

    Do you know whether it reaches the next shift?

    Junior doctor

    I assume so. I change the chart and tell whoever's nearest. I assume that's enough.

    Lontra

    What makes you assume that?

    Junior doctor

    The chart's the record. It's what I was taught. I didn't know there was a separate handover form until you asked.

    Lontra

    When do you make most of your changes?

    Junior doctor

    After the ward round, three, four o'clock. Right before the late shift hands over. Which I suppose is the worst time.

    Lontra

    Is there a way to flag a change for handover?

    Junior doctor

    There's a free-text box on the electronic note. I don't know who reads it.

    Lontra

    Would you do anything differently if you knew?

    Junior doctor

    I'd tell the nurse in charge as well. That's easy, I just don't think of it.

  • Matron, 20 years in nursing Responsible for the handover policy across five wards · 19 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Matron, 20 years in nursing · Responsible for the handover policy across five wards

    Lontra

    How is handover meant to work across the wards you are responsible for?

    Matron

    Bedside handover at the shift change, outgoing and incoming nurse together, with the standard form as a prompt and the electronic chart as the record. We've had that policy for three years.

    Lontra

    How do you know it is followed?

    Matron

    Audit. We observe a sample each quarter. I think we have a good picture.

    Lontra

    What does the form say about medication?

    Matron

    It says 'as per drug chart'. The chart's electronic and always current. So the nurse's job is to look at the chart, not to copy it. Copying would add error.

    Lontra

    What do the wards tell you?

    Matron

    That they don't have time. I take that seriously, but I also think there's some habit in it. The chart is there.

    Lontra

    What would a change made at four look like on the chart?

    Matron

    It would be the current order, with the time. So the information is there.

    Lontra

    Would a nurse starting a shift see, without opening the history, that it had changed?

    Matron

    Not in the headline view, no. You'd have to open the history. That's a fair point. I hadn't thought about it from that side.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Matron

    I'd want to look at the audit again with this in mind. I wouldn't add a line to the form without evidence that people would use it.

    Excerpt from the Deep Study conversation with: Matron, 20 years in nursing · Responsible for the handover policy across five wards

    Lontra

    Last time you wanted to look at the audit again with the chart in mind. Did you?

    Matron

    I did, it's attached. One month, five wards. I'd read it before as good news, because most handovers start on time.

    Lontra

    On Medical B the audit shows bedside handover in 45 of 100 handovers and the medication line updated by hand in 18. What do you make of those two figures?

    Matron

    That the policy and the practice are further apart than I'd said. And that the medication line is updated by hand about one handover in five. I'd assumed higher. I hadn't put those columns side by side.

    Lontra

    Would the wards say the form is a prompt, or a record?

    Matron

    A prompt, and the real information is spoken. I thought that was how it should be. I hadn't thought about what happens when the speaking gets cut short.

    Lontra

    Is there someone else we should talk to about the form?

    Matron

    The clinical systems nurse who looks after the template. She'll know what's been asked for.

  • Bank nurse, 2 years in role Works across wards, a different one most weeks · 13 min

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the conversation with: Bank nurse, 2 years in role · Works across wards, a different one most weeks

    Lontra

    What is handover like for you, working on different wards?

    Bank nurse

    Different every time. Every ward has the same form but each uses it differently. One fills in everything, one just the top. You walk in and work out the local rules.

    Lontra

    What do you do when a box is blank?

    Bank nurse

    That's the thing. Blank might mean nothing's changed, or it might mean nobody got to it. I can't tell. So I ask.

    Lontra

    Who do you ask?

    Bank nurse

    The nurse who's still there. If they've gone, I ring the ward from the last shift.

    Lontra

    How often does that happen?

    Bank nurse

    Most shifts. Two, three calls in the first hour. Plus reading everything again.

    Lontra

    What do you do about medication specifically?

    Bank nurse

    I check the chart for each one and ask at the bedside, 'anything changed today?' People are fine with it. It's just an extra couple of minutes a bay that nobody has counted.

    Lontra

    What would you change?

    Bank nurse

    A line for changes, and everyone fills it in, even if it says none. Then blank means blank.

  • Clinical systems nurse Maintains the handover form template · 11 min · joined in Deep Study

    Read the conversation

    Excerpt from the Deep Study conversation with: Clinical systems nurse · Maintains the handover form template

    Lontra

    The matron suggested we talk to you about the form. How does it change?

    Clinical systems nurse

    It's reviewed once a year. Requests come through the nurse forum and I take them to the matron group. Version three was cut to one side. The change log says 'simplified to one page'. Why that line went rather than another, I can't tell you.

    Lontra

    Has anyone asked for a changes line since?

    Clinical systems nurse

    Five requests in two years, all from wards. They sit in a list. Nobody owns the decision.

    Lontra

    Does the electronic chart show when an order has changed?

    Clinical systems nurse

    In the history, yes. In the headline view, no. Nobody has asked for that to change either.

About this study

The question

“I want to understand how information is passed on at nursing shift handovers, where it gets lost, and what it costs patients and teams.”

A 400-bed general hospital. Ten people took part: six nurses, two of them in charge of a ward, a healthcare assistant, a ward pharmacist, a junior doctor and a matron. Each conversation lasted 5 to 21 minutes. Deep Study went back to three of them and spoke to one colleague the matron suggested.

What Lontra asked about

  1. How a handover runs on a normal shift
  2. What the handover form holds, and what it does not
  3. What happens at the bedside and what happens at the station
  4. What the first hour of a shift is spent on

Ask your results

Answers from 10 conversations and 2 documents

These are questions the organiser asked about this study. Each answer shows the quotes it rests on.

What kind of information is lost at handover?

What changed during the shift. The form carries what stays the same, allergies, mobility, 'as per drug chart', and a change made in the afternoon travels by voice. It reaches the next shift if the person who made it is there, remembers it and is not interrupted.

Nobody in the study described a change that was missed. People described catching them, in the first hour, by re-checking the chart and ringing the last shift.

This study asked about how information moves, not about outcomes, so it cannot say how often something is missed.

Show 3 sources
1
“So you read the chart and think it's always been that.”
Staff nurse, 3 years in role
2
“If she hadn't asked about that bed, I'd have gone home.”
Staff nurse, 12 years in role
3
“I don't see what was done at four unless someone tells me.”
Ward pharmacist, 5 years in role
Would bedside handover fix this?

It helps, because the chart is in front of the nurse and the nurse can ask. But bedside is the policy, not what always happens: it moves to the station when the ward is short, and the audit shows bedside handover from 40 to 73 in 100 across five wards.

In the one ward counted by tick sheet, every station handover fell on a day with a gap in the staffing.

One nurse in charge counted her own ward for two weeks; the audit is the hospital's, for one month.

Show 3 sources
1
“The station version is quicker and it's all voice.”
Nurse in charge, 15 years in role
2
“It wasn't choice, it was the staffing.”
Nurse in charge, 15 years in role · Deep Study
3
“On a bad night the report's all in the office and we only walk the bays after.”
Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role
What does it cost the team?

Time at the start of a shift. Nurses describe ten to twenty minutes of re-checking and phoning, most shifts, and the first drug round waiting behind it. Bank staff add a couple of minutes a bay, asking what a blank box means.

Nobody has counted any of this, so these are the participants' own estimates.

Only estimates; no ward measures the time spent re-checking.

Show 3 sources
1
“Twenty minutes, maybe, most mornings.”
Staff nurse, 3 years in role
2
“Not long, but there's several a night. And the first drug round is waiting.”
Night nurse in charge, 9 years in role
3
“It's just an extra couple of minutes a bay that nobody has counted.”
Bank nurse, 2 years in role
Do nursing management and the wards see the form differently?

Yes. Management treats the form as a prompt and the electronic chart as the record. The wards agree it is a prompt, and add that the chart shows what is current, not what is new.

In Deep Study the matron accepted the point and said she wants the audit read again with it in mind. She would want evidence before adding a line to the form.

One person from nursing management took part.

Show 3 sources
1
“Not in the headline view, no. You'd have to open the history.”
Matron, 20 years in nursing
2
“I hadn't put those columns side by side.”
Matron, 20 years in nursing · Deep Study
3
“Five requests in two years, all from wards.”
Clinical systems nurse · Deep Study

In your own study, you type questions here and Lontra answers from your conversations. Start your own study

Lontra says when the evidence is not enough. It never invents a quote.

Ask your own question

Lontra drafts the topics, you try the conversation yourself, then invite up to ten people. Findings appear after three answers.

Sample study · simulated participants